Sunday, February 1, 2009

O Hindu Parents! O Students! Wake Up, Wake Up

Magh Shuddha Shashti

By OP Gupta IFS (Retd.)

Under section 3 of the National Minority Commission Act, a Hindu cannot be its Chairman and at least five of its seven members including Chairman shall have to be from amongst the minority communities.

Till recently SC Hindus were entitled to get 1500 posts out of every 10000 posts in Government and public sectors, OBC Hindus were entitled to 2700 posts and ST Hindus were entitled for 750 posts.

The National Commission for Scheduled Castes headed by Congressman Shri Buta Singh also favours giving 'reserved' status to Dalit converts to Christianity and Islam but does not want them to be included in the 15% SC quota and wants to further reduce seats available to general class Hindus so as to create a new quota for dalit converts. (Times of India, July 14, 2007). So general category Hindus will get size of their cake further reduced if they vote for any jaichandi party in the coming election.

In January 2007 I returned to India after a gap of thirteen years and was shocked to find just the reverse trend among 'Indian Hindus', rather than demanding equality in all respects, which was guaranteed by the original 1950 Constitution of India, even educated Indian Hindus have been media managed to push their own children and grandchildren into second and third class status vis-à-vis minority candidates by supporting such political parties which openly declare that they will give first preference to minority candidates over Hindu candidates in matters of admissions into nurseries, schools, colleges and universities, employment, departmental promotions, student loans, bank loans

Right from sixties the educational, employment and economic [E3] opportunities for Hindu youngsters especially in the government sector were being reduced bit by bit by all the previous Congress Governments, pace of which has now been accelerated by the Manmohan Singh Government. And irony is that it was and is being done on the strength of those Hindus who support the Congress Party or its UPA partners or the Communist parties.

What I am saying is not imagination but hard bitter fact adversely affecting the employment opportunities of all Hindu youngsters including SC/ST, OBC and Marxist Hindus.

The Hindustan Times of December 24, 2008 (New Delhi edition) reported that in reply to a question the Parliament was informed that as a result of special efforts made by the UPA Government such the share of minorities in central sector jobs increased from 6.9 per cent in 2006-07 to 8.7 per cent in 2007-08. It increased from 7.6 per cent in 2006-07 in the financial sector (Banks, FIs, RBI) to 10.2 per cent; in the Armed Forces from 5.5 per cent to 8.9 per cent, and; in the Railways from 2.7 per cent to 6.3 per cent during the same period.

Consequently, the percentage of Hindus in the central sector declined from 93.1 per cent in 2006-07 to 91.3 per cent in 2007-08. In the financial sector Hindu percentage declined from 92.4 to 89.2, and, in the Armed Forces Hindu percentage declined from 94.5 to 91.1 in just one year.

Who is responsible for reducing percentage of Hindus in jobs? Hindu students, Hindu youth and those Hindu parents who have school and college going children and grand children must pose this question to themselves.

I served as Indian Ambassador for thirteen years (1994-2006); and, as Consul General for another five years (1980-82 and 1985-88). During this long period I found on one hand a burning desire among Hindu settlers abroad to know about their cultural heritage, about Vedas etc, and, on the other hand burning urge among them to be treated with respect and on equal footings with locals in matters of religion, education, employment, economic opportunities and application of laws.

In January 2007, I returned to India after a gap of thirteen years and was shocked to find just the reverse trend among 'Indian Hindus', rather than demanding equality in all respects, which was guaranteed by the original 1950 Constitution of India, even educated Indian Hindus have been media managed to push their own children and grandchildren into second and third class status vis-à-vis minority candidates by supporting such political parties which openly declare that they will give first preference to minority candidates over Hindu candidates in matters of admissions into nurseries, schools, colleges and universities, employment, departmental promotions, student loans, bank loans etc.

I shall place before you some bare facts which show that we Hindu voters have been lacking in parental care and have contributed to reducing our own children to second class status by being careless and casual at times of voting. When I brought these facts to notice of educated Hindus most of them expressed shock on their being ignorant of these facts, and, blamed media and Hindu politicians for this betrayal.

1. Hindu students with better marks are denied admissions into nurseries, schools, colleges and universities run by minorities, whether aided out of taxes collected from we Hindus or unaided.
2. Hindus are generally under represented in the staff of minority institutions, and, posts of principals etc. are generally reserved for non-Hindus. For example, the rule of St Stephan's College Delhi stipulates that a Hindu can not be its Principal and Vice Principal though it receives annual grant of crores of rupees from the government out of taxes collected from we Hindus.
3. These institutions quote Supreme Court decisions to justify the second class treatment of Hindus in matters of admission and employment. In nut shell, the Supreme Court has ruled that Hindus do not enjoy equality rights in the minority institutions whether aided or unaided.
4. The Constitution of India (Articles 15 and 16) guarantees 15 per cent reservations for SC Hindus and 7.5 per cent reservations for ST Hindus but they are denied these constitutionally guaranteed reservations in admissions as well as in employment in minority institutions with connivance of Jaichandi Hindu politicians, who, are also known as 'secular' or 'pseudo-secular' politicians.
5. The OBC Hindus have been given 27 per cent reservations under the Constitution in academic institutions but the Manmohan Singh Government has framed rules in such a way that OBC Hindus are denied this reservation all over India in minority institutions.
6. Now through the Rangnath Mishra Commission the UPA Government of Manmohan Singh with help of all political parties (Mulayam Singh Yadav, Mayawati, Lalu Yadav, Ram Vilash Paswan, K Karunanidhi etc) except BJP is trying to include Muslims and Christians in the SC category which will naturally reduce the size of cake available to all SC Hindu candidates in schools and colleges as well as in employment in government and public sector.
7. Further, the Christians and Muslims enjoy higher literacy rate than SC Hindus. So if the Manmohan Singh Government succeeds to include Muslims and Christians into SC category, the SC/ST Hindus will further lose heavily in educational sector as well as in employment sector.
8. The National Commission for Scheduled Castes headed by Congressman Shri Buta Singh also favours giving 'reserved' status to Dalit converts to Christianity and Islam but does not want them to be included in the 15 per cent SC quota and wants to further reduce seats available to general class Hindus so as to create a new quota for dalit converts. (Times of India, July 14, 2007). So general category Hindus will get size of their cake further reduced if they vote for any Jaichandi party in the coming election.
9. Hindu students get student loans at higher interest rate of about 12 per cent to 14 per cent per annum but minority students get student loan at 3 per cent per annum from the National Minority Development & Finance Corporation under the Union Ministry of Finance. For confirmation please visit www.nmdfc.org. This discrimination against Hindu students has been made possible by those Hindus who voted to Congress Party in previous elections.
10. Hindu youth gets loans from commercial banks to start a new business at 15 per cent to 18 per cent interest and has to arrange 'margin money' of 15 per cent to 40 per cent of project cost from his private sources, balance comes from the bank. But a minority youth has to put in only 5 per cent of project cost as margin money from his private source, other 35 per cent is given by the National Minority Development & Finance Corporation at 3 per cent interest, and remaining 60 per cent of finance is given by commercial banks at two percentage points less than general lending rate for Hindus.

How can a Hindu youth compete in business with minority businesman?

This point has to be replied by those Hindus who give their notes and votes to Congress Party or to any UPA Party. For this discrimination those Hindus are responsible who give their votes to Congress Party or to any Jaichandi Party.

* The Manmohan Singh Government has directed that all minority students admitted to 50 top institutions of India like IIMs, IITs etc (list enclosed) will get their total fees paid by the government but Hindu students, whether leftist or rightist have to pay their fees even if they are members of the NSUI or SFI.
* If a minority student decides to join any coaching centre to prepare for admission into colleges or public service examinations or jobs in government and private sectors he gets total fees of coaching centre paid by the government but a Hindu student or his parent has to pay the fees of coaching centre. Details may be seen at www.minorityaffairs.gov.in
* As follow up of the recommendations of Sachar Committee, the UPA Government has announced lakhs of scholarships exclusively for school-going children of minorities. At pre-matric and at post-matric level a minority student will get scholarship if he has secured not less than 50 per cent marks in the previous year examination but such facility is not there for Hindu students. According to one such scheme children belonging to minorities whose parents have an annual income of Rs. 2.50 lakh are entitled to get a scholarship subject to fulfilling certain minimum conditions. But Hindu students whose parents earn even less than Rs 2,000 per month, cannot get a scholarship. Such perverse discrimination against Hindus was practiced by Aurangzeb. So, a Hindu vote to Congress Party is as good as giving vote to Aurangzeb.
* It may come as total surprise to many Hindus that there are many posts under the government which are paid out of taxes collected from we Hindus but a Hindu howsoever liberal or Marxist he may be, he is legally debarred from holding such posts such as posts of the Chairman of National and Provincial Minority Commissions, principals of St Stephan's Delhi (and similar minority institutions running into thousands and thousands all over India) etc.
* Under section 3 of the National Minority Commission Act, a Hindu can not be its Chairman and at least five of its seven members including Chairman shall have to be from amongst the minority communities. This law was enacted by PV Narasimha Rao Government.
* Section 4 of the National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions Act 2004 passed by the Manmohan Singh Government stipulates that only persons from minority communities shall be eligible to be appointed as Chairman and members of this Commission. Hindus have been excluded from this Commission.
* It is a great shame that such anti-Hindu laws were framed and passed by Hindu politicians who were elected on strength of Hindu votes.
* In pursuance of the 2004 Congress manifesto, on March 10, 2006, the Lok Sabha passed the National Commission for Minority Educational (Amendment) Bill according to which the provincial governments will have to give no objection certificate within 90 days of application for setting up an institution by religious minorities, or, else the government will have to specify reasons for refusal. The aggrieved party will have right to approach the Commission which, in turn, will take a final decision in consultation with the State. Composition of even this Commission is not representative to the total exclusion of Hindus and the wonder is that Hindus, howsoever secular or leftist, are debarred from being made even a member of this Commission by an Act of Parliament passed in November 2004. However, if no reasons are given by a State Government for not giving the NOC within 90 days, it would be deemed as the approval of the State. The Act also provides for the right of minority institutions to seek affiliation to any university of their choice listed in this Act. The bill was supported by all UPA partners including the Left parties, Samajwadi Party of Shri Mulayam Singh and the Bahujan Samaj Party etc. It was criticised by the Bharatiya Janata Party. So, a Muslim institution in a far off place, say, Jhumari talaian in Bihar can demand affiliation to any named central university of its choice and its students will get degrees of that central university and, thus, will enjoy better marketability in the employment market whereas a Hindu student of the same region will have degree of a provincial university having less marketability in the employment market. Thus, with votes of Hindu parents, the UPA Government has placed Muslim and Christian students at higher and better pedestal in the employment market than Hindu students. Those Hindu parents in rural areas who voted for the Congress Party and its Jaichandi allies in the 2004 election have thus actually harmed the future of their own children.
* To increase the percentage of minorities in the government sector the UPA government has ordered inclusion of minority members in all Selection Boards and Departmental Promotion Committees (DPCs). Rangnath Mishra, a Congress Member of Parliament, heading a Commission has recommended reserving 15 per cent of jobs in all recruitments and promotions for minority candidates.

At present Hindus constitute over 95 per cent in all services and the Manmohan Singh Government with the help of Hindu voters is trying to reduce the Hindu percentage in government and public sector undertakings to less than 85 per cent. Size of cake for Hindus is being reduced by the Congress Party, that, too, riding on shoulders of Hindus.

Till May 2004 Hindus could theoretically compete for all 100 per cent jobs under the government but now they would compete only for 85 per cent of jobs as the size of cake has been/is going to be reduced by 15 per cent by the UPA for all categories of Hindus in terms of the Rangnath Mishra Commission whether you are a Marxist Hindu or a rightist Hindu, whether you are a communal Hindu or a secular Hindu, whether you are a SC/ST Hindu or not, whether you are an upper caste or lower caste Hindu, whether you are OBC or non-OBC Hindu, whether you are a North Indian Hindu or South Indian Hindu.

This reduction of 15 per cent shall be applicable to all categories of Hindus including SC, ST, OBC, neo-liberals and Marxists as the minorities, according to Manmohan Singh, have the first claim over the national resources, so Hindus shall have access to left overs.

Till recently SC Hindus were entitled to get 1,500 posts out of every 10,000 posts in Government and public sectors, OBC Hindus were entitled to 2,700 posts and ST Hindus were entitled for 750 posts.
The UPA Government is planning to reserve 15 per cent posts for minorities, and as Manmohan Singh has publicly asserted that minorities have first claim over government resources so SC Hindus can compete for 15 per cent of remaining 8,500 posts i.e. 1270 posts, OBC Hindus will get 27 per cent of 8500 i.e. 2,290 posts and ST Hindus will get 7.5 per cent of 8,500 i.e. 630 posts. The upper castes Hindu candidates till 2005 were eligible to compete for 5,050 posts out of 10,000 but now under Sonia Gandhi-Manmohan formula they can compete only for 4,310 seats. And wonder of wonder is that this reduction in E3 space of Hindu applicants will be achieved on strength of those Hindus who will give their notes and votes to Congress Party or to any other Jaichandi parties in the coming elections.

And another wonder of wonder is that without any protest the Manmohan Singh Government has succeeded in reducing percentage of Hindus in job sectors riding on shoulders of those Hindus who voted for Congress and other UPA parties in the 2004 general election.

Thus, it is clear that Jaichandi Hindu politicians have treacherously created such a system in which a minority is eligible to apply for each and every post paid by the State but not a Hindu. A minority student gets student loan and commercial loans at rates lower than a Hindu. A minority student with more than 50 per cent marks gets scholarship but not a Hindu student. In minority run institutions a Hindu is given stepbrotherly treatment in matters of admissions and employment but in Hindu run institutions a minority candidate has to be treated on par with Hindus and to ensure that a minority is treated on par there are national and provincial minority commissions headed by minorities.

Hindu voters have reduced themselves to second and third class status either by abstaining from voting or by voting to Jaichandi Hindu politicians.

Source: organiser.org

Nepalese convert to Islam for work

http://www.speroforum.com/a/17927/Nepalese-convert-to-Islam-for-work

More and more Nepalese emigrants who have gone to Muslim majority countries to work - for example, on the Arabian Peninsula - are abandoning their Hindu religion and embracing Islam in order to improve their economic and social situation.

According to figures from the Nepalese workers' union, in Qatar alone there have been about 2,000 cases of conversion, plus 4,000 in Saudi Arabia, the Arab emirates, and Malaysia.

Rita Tamang, who emigrated to Saudi Arabia two years ago from the Nepalese district of Dhulikhel, explains that "Muslims get privileges with better work and good pay. The workers from other religions are hardly trusted by private employers. So, I myself also adopted Islam, giving up Hinduism." It's the same story for Manoj Karki, who left Kathmandu to go to work on an oil rig in Qatar. "I was hardly managing to save money from my salary, but since I have changed my religion to Islam, I am now more safe, comfortable, and with easy access to jobs.” His wife, who works as a maid in Doha, followed her husband's example: “My husband converted to Islam and he advised me to do the same, so I did."

On the basis of numbers provided by the Nepalese workers' union, and under pressure from the complaints of immigrants and their relatives in Nepal, the foreign minister in Kathmandu has decided to take measures to stop the wave of conversions. Upendra Mahato says he has "instructed our diplomatic missions to probe the cases and stop such conversions if they come through pressure or by force."

According to estimates by the Nonresidential Nepalese Association, of the almost 7 million citizens of the Asian country who are working abroad, more than 400,000 are in the Gulf region. Of the 55 countries in which Nepalese immigrants are living, the most common destinations for those seeking work are Saudi Arabia and Malaysia, both Muslim majority countries.

By sending part of their earnings back home, emigrants represent one of the main sources of income for Nepal.

Friday, January 30, 2009

Azamgarh Jihadi's denigrates National Flag in National Capital - Media silent as usual!


The Image you see here was published in BBC Website under the title 'Indian Muslims in Torture rally'

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/7857468.stm

Well and good each and every citizen has their right to protest against any so called atrocities in our democratic setup.

But does that freedom to protest means to denigrate our Nation and our National flag?

In the image one can see 3 Indian flags held upside down – That too in the National capital!

To expect New Delhi Government or Central Government to take any case against them citing this reason is too unlikely.

Sadly not even a TV Channel which preach pseudo-patriotism haven’t uttered any word against this denigration of our National flag .

Yes all of them are busy counting the number of arrests made from Mangalore in connection with pub attack


बदलना है भविष्य तो विद्रोह करो

Tarun Vijay
कभी कुछ न सहने और जो अभी तक जो कुछ मानते आए उसे कसौटी पर कसने और लगे तो नकारने, अस्वीकारने का स्वभाव भी पालना चाहिए। जो ठीक न लगे उसे क्यों सहें? और जो मन न माने उसे भी जीने का सामान जुटाने की मजबूरी में क्यों मानते रहें? नेपाल में प्रचंड ने पशुपतिनाथ से छेड़छाड़ की तो जो अभी तक डरे सहमे सब कुछ चुपचाप सह रहे थे वे भी विद्रोह में उठ खड़े हुए, माओवादी अहंकार ढीला पड़ा। जो लोग तोलते हैं कि नुकसान क्या और कितना होगा, उसके बाद तय किया जाए कि बोलें या न बोलें, वे केंचुए के कबीले में रहते हैं। तेईस साल की उम्र में भगत सिंह निडर विद्रोह कर वह कमा गए जो करोड़पति रायबहादुर ब्रिटिश चाटुकार होकर छू भी न पाए थे। विवेकानंद तो पैंतीस के ही थे कि संसार छोड़ गए पर संसार उन्हें अब भी याद करता है -12 जनवरी को सरकारी स्तर पर नहीं, जनता के असरकारी स्तर पर विवेकानंद का जन्मदिन मनाया गया था। उनके जीवन का एक ही मूल परिचय था - आमि विद्रोही चिर अशांत। लीक पर नहीं चलना। जो गलत लगे उसे नहीं मानना, जो सही है उसके प्रसार के लिए गत्ते के डिब्बों में भी रात बितानी पड़े तो मंजूर। यानी जीएं भले ही थोड़ा, पर आग धधकती हो , रोशनी फैलाते हुए। धुएं की तरह सुलग-सुलग कर लंबे जीने से अच्छा है आत्महत्या कर लो , बोझ मत बनो।

पर आज यह बताना, विवेकानंद को याद करना खतरे से खाली नहीं। जरा कह कर देखिए कि ये मंदिर वाले अपने देव, आराध्य पूजने की जगहें इतनी गंदी क्यों रखते हैं। काशी विश्वनाथ मंदिर जाने की गली क्यों है कीचड़ भरी और ये पंडे, अपने जजमानों को इतने अभद्र और अमानवीय ढंग से क्यों लूटते हैं? वृंदावन में सिर घुटाए विधवाओं को देख कर हम क्यों मुंह फेर लेते हैं और उस समय राधे-राधे कह कर पलायनवादी अबूझी धार्मिकता का पाखंड औढ़ते हैं जब सारा हिंदू समाज युद्ध भूमि में आक्रमण झेल रहा हो ? क्या यह समय मंदिरों में घंटियां बजा-बजा कर अपने पाप शमन करने के जुगुप्साजनक कर्म का है या आनंदमठ के उस संन्यासी विद्रोह के तेवर फिर सुलगाने का जो धर्म को राष्ट्र से विलग कर देखता ही नहीं? देश बचेगा तो देवताओं के लिए भी जगह बचेगी। वरना तक्षशिला, रावलपिंडी, मुल्तान और कराची हो जाओगे - यह बताने अब कोई नहीं आता।

गंगा की पूजा-आरती करने वालों ने गंगा गंदला दी, पर खम यों ठोंकते हैं मानो युद्ध-सज्ज रणबांकुरे हों। जिसकी स्मृति ही लुप्त है और सीने में है संसद का बाजार, वह संस्कृति के उद्धार की, सभ्यता के संरक्षण की बात करे तो कौन गंभीरता से लेगा? ये उस देश के लोग हैं जहां दशरथ के वानप्रस्थी मन और जनक के वीतरागी स्वभाव पर मन मथने वाले व्याख्यान होते हैं और तब भी सत्ता राजनीति का खेल खेलते हैं। गो हाथ में जुंबिश नहीं, आंखों में तो दम है, रहने दो अभी सागरो मीना मेरे आगे। धन्य हैं आप। आपकी जीवन कथाएं, आचरण, शब्द शक्ति आने वाली पीढ़ियों को निस्संदेह ‘ प्रेरित ’ करेंगी।

थक रही आंखें विद्रोह का पोकरण देखना चाहती हैं। राजनीतिक मूर्ति पूजन के विरूद्ध कोई मूलशंकर पाखंड खंडिनी पताका लेकर आए या विवेकानंद का साहस सीने में समाए असंदिग्ध हिंदू निष्ठा को हिंद महासागर की उत्ताल तरंगे नापते हुए पुन : घोषित करे तो इन वोट भय से आक्रांत अंधेरे के टुकड़ों को जनता के अस्वीकार की परची थमाई जा सकेगी। भारत का नवीन कायाकल्प नूतन धर्मचेतना के उदय-पथ से ही होगा। जब ईश्वर चंद्र विद्यासागर, दयानंद हुए, या हेडगेवार ने वह कर दिखाने के लिए पांच सहयोगियों को लेकर संघ गढ़ा, जो पहले कभी हिंदू समाज ने देखा न था, तो वे भी अपने वक्त के विद्रोही, चिर अशांत थे। श्यामा प्रसाद मुखर्जी और दीनदयाल, दोनों ही अकाल कालकवलित हुए, इसी विद्रोही, अशांत परम्परा के जाज्वल्यमान नक्षत्र थे।

जब विवेकानंद ने स्वदेश मंत्र दिया और कहा कि जिन्हें तुम नीच, चांडाल, अब्राह्मण कहते हुए दुत्कारते हो , वे सब तुम्हारे रक्त बंधु, तुम्हारे भाई हैं , जब उन्होंने बचपन, यौवन और वार्धक्य के अध्यात्म को भारत के रंग में रंगा, जब अरविंद ने देश को भवानी-भारती के रूप में स्थापित किया तो वे सब अपने समय की धारा को बदल रहे थे, सड़ चुकी परंपराओं के विरूद्ध चट्टान बने थे। बुझ चुके चिरागों के थके हुए दीपदान हमारा पथ आलोकित नहीं कर सकते। हिसाब मांगने का वक्त अब है। गांधी और दीनदयाल को पूजने की जरूरत नहीं, उनके नाम पर रास्ते, बगीचे, बाजार और इमारतें खड़ी करना, चलो ठीक होगा, पर उन्हें मानते हो तो उन्हें जियो , जीकर दिखाओ।

व्यक्ति नहीं रास्ता महत्वपूर्ण होता है। बचाता रास्ता है, व्यक्ति नहीं। रास्ता भूले तो फिर हमारी वाणी और व्यवहार प्रभाहीन हो जाते हैं। अब देखिए, कहीं गोहत्या बंद नहीं हुई। पर हम गोभक्त हैं। कही मतांतरण बंद नही हुआ, पर हम मतांतरण विरोधी हैं। कहीं हमारे हाथों भारतीय भाषाओं का सम्मान नहीं बढ़ा, पर हम भारतीयता के प्रहरी हैं। हम मंदिरों के रक्षक और सर्जक हैं, पर सरकारी नियंत्रण से कोई मंदिर बाहर निकाल नहीं पाए। हम देवी उपासक हैं, पर कन्या भ्रूण हत्या रोक पाते नहीं। हम राष्ट्र रक्षक हैं, पर कोई भी अपने चुनाव घोषणा पत्र में यह कसम खाने से डरता है कि सत्ता में आए तो हमारी जो एक लाख पच्चीस हजार वर्ग किलोमीटर जमीन चीन और पाकिस्तान ने हड़पी हुई है, उसे वापस लेने के संसद के सर्वसम्मत प्रस्ताव को हम क्रियान्वित करेंगे।

हम बगल के गांव जाते हैं तो अर्धचंद्राकार टोपी पहन कर अस्सलामवालेकुम कहते हैं। तुम्हारे गांव आते हैं तो सिर पर गोंद से शिखा चिपका कर रामनामी औढ़ लेते हैं। अब हमें न वोट दीजिएगा तो किसे दीजिएगा? हम जातितोड़क समरसता के सम्मेलन से दफ्तर लौटते हैं तो जाति के सर्टिफिकेट जांच कर चुनाव के टिकट बांटते हैं। वोट के हकदार हम ही तो हुए फिर। हम बहुत कुछ हैं, पर हम कुछ भी नहीं हैं। प्लीज हमें वोट दो ना? यह सेक्युलर चलन या असेक्युलर भ्रम तोड़ने के लिए विवेकानंद के घनप्रहार की ही प्रतीक्षा है। डरोगे तो मरोगे, मरने का डर न होगा, तभी पाओगे। अमरनाथ से पशुपतिनाथ के प्रसंग यही बताते हैं। पर यह स्थिति बहुत कम परिणाम में दिखती है। हम अजर, अमर, अविनाशी आत्मा वाले, जो कहते हैं कि चोला ही बदलता है, आत्मा नहीं, कितना डरते हैं खड़े होकर इनकार के स्वर गुंजाने में।

इसलिए विवेकानंद, हेडगेवार को याद करने, जीने की जरूत है। ठहराए हुए पानी में काई बहुत जमी है। उसे साफ करने के लिए तो कुदाली, घन और पत्थरों की ही जरूरत होगी। हर आंदोलन अपनी नई भाषा गढ़ता है, भारत भी नई भाषा गढ़े - उषा के साथ उन्मीलित होते सरोज की नाई। इस उषा काल में अगर नए भारत के अग्रणी भिन्न भाषा और मुहावरे भी बोल रहे हैं तो गंभीरता का तकाजा है उन्हें आगे बढ़ते देख मुदित हुआ जाए। हर कोई सिर्फ हमारी भाषा, हमारे सोच, हमारे शब्द - संसार के चर्च से बपतिस्मा लिए हो तभी हम उसे अपना कहेंगे, लेकिन यह चर्चीकरण करते हुए भी खुद को उस परंपरा का ध्वजवाहक कहेंगे जो चार्वाक के मतवैभिन्य को सम्मान देती है और किसी गैलीलियो को सजा नहीं देती - तो यह दोहरापन चलेगा नहीं। आकाश में सूराख हो सकता है, जरूरत सिर्फ तबीयत के साथ एक पत्थर उछालने की होती है। दुष्यंत कुमार ने वही कहा जो सच उन्होंने देखा था। इसलिए भक्ति से स्पंदित पशुपतिनाथ के आराधकों के लिए विद्रोह की अर्चना कर नवीन पाशुपातास्त्र के उपयोग की सिद्धता चाहिए। यह सिद्धता संसद मार्ग से नहीं आनंदमठ के स्वयं स्वीकृत कंटकाकीर्ण संघ पथ से मिलेगी।

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Dealing with Islamist terror

Barry Rubin

Hamas and Hizbullah, Iran, Muslim Brotherhood, and even Islamist impersonator Syria, are not persuadable through dialogue. They glory in death and won't rest till they achieve 'total victory'

David Grossman, an Israeli writer, has penned an essay entitled "Israel's success in Gaza only proves it is strong, not right." Aside from the irony of his being Israeli, Grossman's ideas are the ultimate expression of Western reaction to the terrorist -extremist challenge.

To his credit, Grossman notes there have been Palestinian 'crimes and mistakes', that the other side prefers violence, and that ignoring this "would be tantamount to belittling and condescending to them, as if they were not mature adults with minds of their own, responsible for their own decisions and failures."

But, he concludes, since Israel is stronger, it somehow controls the conflict's level of violence, able to be "calming it down and even bringing it to an end." How, he asks, will peace "ever come if we fail to comprehend just how grave is the responsibility that lies on our shoulders" for achieving it?

Grossman is upset that Israelis feel united and confident, complaining about, "Those who have taught us over the years to scoff at belief in peace and any hope for change in our relations with the Arabs. Those who have convinced us that the Arabs understand only force, and therefore that is the only language we can use in our dealings with them."

He adds, "And because we have spoken to them for so long in that language... we have forgotten that there are other languages for speaking to human beings, even to enemies, even bitter foes like Hamas" not just "the language of planes and tanks".

The reason why almost everyone in Israel disagrees with Grossman, however, isn't that they have forgotten anything but that they remember so accurately. It is no accident that Grossman's article is so vague and ahistorical because for him to cite specific examples must raise the sad fact that "those who have taught us over the years to scoff at belief in peace and any hope for change in our relations with the Arabs", are the Palestinians themselves.

Why doesn't he mention the 1993-2000 peace process experience? Why not one word about radical Islamism? Because what undercuts his claims are two realities he won't face and a psychological crutch that he and some others understandably cannot do without.

The first reality is that Israel remembers the Palestinian and Syrian rejection of peace. From 1993 to 2000, Israel made deep concessions and took great risks. The Palestinian leadership and Syria turned down a plan which included returning the entire Golan Heights and establishing an independent Palestinian state with east Jerusalem as its capital.

Grossman and those thinking like him forget that Palestinian rejection of peace makes Israelis conclude logically that Palestinians aren't ready to make peace. Even Fatah forces in Gaza -- the 'moderates' -- brag not only about firing more than 100 rockets at Israel but also of fighting alongside Islamic jihad, a group even more extreme than Hamas!

The second reality he ignores is radical Islamism's rise. Hamas and Hizbullah, Iran, Muslim Brotherhoods, and even Islamist impersonator Syria, aren't persuadable through dialogue. They reject all lessons of West Asia's last 60 years. They want to fight for decades; they expect total victory.

Israelis know these forces won't be moderated by Israeli words or deeds. Grossman's good will doesn't interest the other side. Nice well-meaning people who oppose violence, advocate compromise, and offer huge concessions face those wanting to wipe them off the map, rejecting compromise, and interpreting other's concessions as surrender.

It's no accident that Grossman and those who talk like him know little of West Asia politics and have less contact with Arabs or Muslims than those disagreeing with them. Hamas has no difficulty believing such people exist because they embody the Islamists' stereotype of a weak West fearing violence, begging for mercy, and being easily beaten.

Part of dialogue is to hear what the other side says. Do so with Hamas and Iran; see if you still believe in dialogue. Here is what key Hamas leader Ismail Radwan said in a post-war victory rally: "Gaza is not our goal. The liberation of all of Palestine, from the (Jordan) river to the (Mediterranean) sea, god willing, will be achieved." Sorry, David, I don't think you are going to make him change his mind.

That brings us to the psychological crutch: Wishful thinking. It's hard to face a life-long confrontation with evil forces seeking your utter destruction. It's unpleasant to admit there's no alternative to waging that struggle.

In contrast, it's empowering to say: We can solve this with words and sensitivity. That's why Grossman sounds sensible to outsiders knowing little and irrelevant to those understanding the specific situation:

"We must initiate speech," says Grossman, "insist on speech, let no one put us off." It doesn't matter if "dialogue seems hopeless from the start" because it will protect us far more than "hundreds of planes dropping bombs." Why is that? Because we will all come to our senses once we understand how much harm we do to each other and how 'utterly senseless' is violence.

Talk is cheap. How strange is the assumption that once both sides grasp the horror of killing their enemies they'll be repelled. But Hamas isn't repelled it's thrilled. As for the idea that violence is 'senseless', Hamas thinks it a glorious means to its goal.

There is, of course, an alternative dialogue with Palestinians and Arabs. Deal with the Palestinian Authority -- without illusions -- for minimum violence and maximum mutual benefit. Cooperate with Arab states that hate Hamas, the Islamists and Iran because of their own interests. But this requires intimidating, deterring, weakening, and discrediting Hamas. Which is why the Gaza war was imperative and concessions to Hamas are disastrous.

Beyond strategic considerations is a profound trauma, a bewildering contradiction to everything the Western intellectual, artist or policymaker holds dear. Enlightenment man meets the Dark Ages' advocate who sneers at reason; realpolitik man meets those indifferent to interests; materialistic man meets those repelled by materialism; and humanistic man meets those who glory in death and destruction.

-- The writer is Director of the Gloria Center, Jerusalem, and Editor of MERIA journal.

Tuesday, January 27, 2009

The Real Talibans of India

Dinesh Krishna

When a female journalist called Soumya Vishwanathan was killed in India'a national capital, the Chief Minister of Delhi Smt Sheila Dixit blamed the dead female journalist for her own tragedy by saying that she was too adventurous. The Media wholeheartedly supported Mrs Dixit and went gaga over her shortly afterwards, when she won the Delhi Assembly elections.

When Scarlett Keeling was raped and killed in Goa and the needle of suspicion pointed to a strong nexus between the Goan Ministers, the drug mafia and the sex racketeers, the media played it very safe by conveniently choosing not to pursue the leads from the investigation.

When a 14-year-old German girl was raped by Rohit Monserrate, the 21-year-old son of Goa Education Minister Atanasio Monserrate who is also a powerful political figure in Goa, and the girl's mother was repeatedly harassed and their lawyer was grievously injured in order to coerce him to withdraw from the case, the Media didn't find anything extraordinary in that.

When Taslima Nasreen's press conference was rudely disrupted and chairs and all sorts of dangerous objects were thrown at her in full glare of the cameras by the "secular" muslim jihadis of Hyderabad lead by the MLAs of Majlis Ittehadul Muslimeen (MIM), the Media didnt at all find anything amiss in that.

When Laxmi Oraon, an Adivasi woman was brutally thrashed and paraded naked through the streets of Guwahati, Assam, with the whole police paraphernalia and official state machinery in tow, the Media chose to downplay the episode since, the victim was a hapless adivasi woman from the lower strata of society.

The Media felt that since all the above unsavoury incidents had occured in the states lead by Madam Sonia Antonia Maino's puppets, it is all perfectly legitimate and absolutely secular and progressive.

Kudos to the Media who are the Real Talibans of India.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Slumdog is about defaming Hindus

The pioneer

Kanchan Gupta

In keeping with American politics of the times, Slumdog Millionaire has been nominated for as many as 10 Oscars and our deracinated media, which constantly looks for inspirational ‘good news’ stories that invariably revolve around Western appreciation of ‘truthful’ portrayal of the Indian ‘reality’, has gone into a tizzy. Saturday’s edition of a newspaper published from New Delhi had a blurb on the front page that read, “The Slumdog story: How ‘Danny uncle’ and his ‘moral compass’ created the biggest ‘Indian’ blockbuster — and why you should watch it.” Predictably, the chattering classes, who had been blissfully ignorant of Vikas Swarup’s Q and A (as they had been of Aravind Adiga’s The White Tiger till its perverse denigration of India and all things Indian wowed the judges of last year’s Man Booker prize) are now making a beeline for the nearest bookshop for a copy of the novel, whose title has been suitably changed to Slumdog Millionaire so that the book and the film are eponymous and both publisher and producer can encash the extraordinary hype that has been generated. Late last year, there was similar hoopla over AR Rahman getting the Golden Globe award for the music he has scored for Slumdog Millionaire. An approving pat on the back by the Hollywood Foreign Press Association, it would seem, is the most important marker in an artiste’s career. Those Indian musicians who haven’t got the Golden Globe are not worthy of honour at home just as Sahitya Akademi award winners are not worthy of finding space on our bookshelves, leave alone feature on news pages or news bulletins.

The larger point is not really about going gaga over an American award or a British prize, but how they are seen as India being admitted into the charmed circle whose membership is strictly controlled and is by invitation only. That invitation invariably follows a certain pattern; it’s not merely the keepers of the gate chanting, “Eeny meeny miny mo, catch a tiger by his toe, if he hollers let him go…” Apart from the fact that the ‘tigers’ in this case are not hollering but salivating at the prospect of seeing themselves clutching a handful of trophies on Oscar night, the nomination process is far more rigorous than we would think, with filters to keep out those films and books that do not serve the judges’ purpose or pander to their fanciful notions — in this case, of India. Aravind Adiga crafted his novel in a manner that it could not but impress the Man Booker judges who see India as a seething mass of unwashed hordes which worship pagan gods, are trapped in caste-based prejudices, indulge in abominable practices like untouchability, and are not worthy of being considered as an emerging power, never mind economic growth and knowledge excellence. Similarly, Danny Boyle has made a film that portrays every possible bias against India and structured it within the matrix of Western lib-left perceptions of the Indian ‘reality’ which have little or nothing in common with the real India in which we live.

Therefore, it is not surprising that Boyle’s film is about a slum where extreme social exclusion, political suppression and economic deprivation define the lives of its inhabitants. He has made every effort to shock and awe the film’s audience by taking recourse to graphic and gory portrayal of bloodthirsty Hindu mobs on the rampage — the idiom that defines India as it is imagined by the lib-left Western mind — laying to waste Muslim lives (a Hindu is shown slitting a Muslim woman’s throat in an almost frame-by-frame remake of the videotape that was released by the killers of Daniel Pearl) and property. There’s more that makes you want to throw up the last meal you had: Hindu policemen torturing Muslims by giving them ‘electric shock therapy’, street children being physically disfigured and then forced to beg, and such other scenes of a medieval society where rule of law does not exist and every Hindu is a rapacious monster eager to make a feast of helpless Muslims.

Nor is it surprising that Boyle should have cunningly changed the name of the film’s — as also the book’s — protagonist from Vikas Swarup’s Ram Mohammad Thomas (a sort of tribute to the Amar Akbar Antony brand of ‘secularism’ which was fashionable in the 1970s) to Jamal Malik. The name implies a Kashmiri connection, and we can’t put it beyond Boyle suggesting a link between Jamal’s travails — it is his mother whose throat is shown as being slit by a Hindu — and the imagined victimhood of Kashmir’s Muslims who, the lib-left intelligentsia in the West insists, are ‘persecuted by Hindu India’. Asked about the protagonist’s name being changed, Swarup is believed to have said that it was done to “make it sound more politically correct”. There is a second hidden message: The Hindu quizmaster on the ‘Who Wants to be a Millionaire?’ show has doubts about Jamal, who gets all the questions right, not because he is a ‘slumdog’ but because he is a Muslim; so he sets India’s Hindu police on the hapless boy. Swarup did not quite put it that way in his book, but the film does so, and understandably the critics in Hollywood who sport Obama buttons are impressed.

The last time depravity was portrayed as the Indian ‘reality’ was when Roland Joffé did a cinematic version of Dominique Lapierre’s City of Joy. In that film, the Missionaries of Charity were shown as the saviours of an India trapped in filth, squalor, poverty and Hindu superstition. Some two decades later, Boyle has rediscovered Joffé’s India and made appropriate changes to fit his film into the Hindu-bad-Muslim-good mould so that it has a resonance in today’s America where it is now fashionable to look at the world through the eyes of Barack Hussein Obama.

In her review of the film, “Shocked by Slumdog’s poverty porn”, Alice Miles writes in The Times: “Like the bestselling novel by the Americanised Afghan Khaled Hosseini, A Thousand Splendid Suns, Slumdog Millionaire is not a million miles away from a form of pornographic voyeurism. Slumdog Millionaire is poverty porn.” Commenting on the BBFC's decision to “place this work in the comedy genre”, she says, “Comedy? So maybe that’s it: I just didn't get the joke.” It’s doubtful whether most Indians, Hindus and Muslims, would get it either if they were to watch Slumdog Millionaire.

kanchangupta@rocketmail.com